BrickLink Discussion Forum

In Inventories Requests, therobo writes:

In Inventories Requests, Hygrotus writes:

In Inventories Requests, samsam2 writes:

Please make changes to the following inventory: [M=sw534]

* Change 1 Part Red {553pb016 Brick, Round 2 x 2 Dome Top with Silver Pattern (R4-P17 / Astromech Droid)) to 553pb023 Brick, Round 2 x 2 Dome Top with Silver Band around Dome Pattern (R4-P17)}

Comments from Submitter:
dome top is with silver band version. Existing image of 553pb016 (should not have silver band) in red shows the silver band. Silver band version is part 553pb023

Sorry for long waiting, but I wanted to study this problem, which looked like
easy one on the first sight.
Good catch, I didn't notice it when I was submiting new replacment image
for red

553pb016 Brick, Round 2 x 2 Dome Top with Silver Pattern (R4-P17)
Parts: Brick, Round, Decorated

I didn't do inventory for [m=sw534], so somebody else used part 553pb016
in its inventory submission and then I submited only new image to replace one
being for this part in red color submited before by inventory submitter of this
minifg and didn't compare them in that time (as I remember it was 2014

).

I created 553pb016 and 553pb023 for different astomechs which I inventoried:
[m=sw456] and [m=sw706]

So you excellently noticed that dome for sw534 has silver stripe, I appreciate
this.
I this post I attached comparison images of all three astromech.

But I think we should create completely new unique dome for this particualr droid.
Why? Look at the droid indicator on dome in sw534 is lime but in sw706 having
part 553pb023 is blue

This is difference in pattern printing recognized in similar parts in catalog:

553pb017a Brick, Round 2 x 2 Dome Top with Red Dots, Small Receptor and Dark Blue Pattern (R2-D2)
Parts: Brick, Round, Decorated

553pb017b Brick, Round 2 x 2 Dome Top with Lavender Dots, Small Receptor and Dark Blue Pattern (R2-D2)
Parts: Brick, Round, Decorated

So summarizing
- photo of dome for sw534 is correct
- dome for sw534 is classified under wrong entry
- sw534 has unique pattern printing which should have own catalog entry.

Here it is:

553pb034 Brick, Round 2 x 2 Dome Top with Silver Band Around Dome, Lime Dot Pattern (Astromech Droid)
Parts: Brick, Round, Decorated

Thanks

Author:

therobo

Posted:

Dec 13, 2018 10:57

Subject:

Re: Inventory Change Request for Minifig sw534

Viewed:

30 times

Topic:

In Inventories Requests, Hygrotus writes:

In Inventories Requests, samsam2 writes:

Sorry for long waiting, but I wanted to study this problem, which looked like
easy one on the first sight.
Good catch, I didn't notice it when I was submiting new replacment image
for red

553pb016 Brick, Round 2 x 2 Dome Top with Silver Pattern (R4-P17)
Parts: Brick, Round, Decorated

).

I created 553pb016 and 553pb023 for different astomechs which I inventoried:
[m=sw456] and [m=sw706]

This is difference in pattern printing recognized in similar parts in catalog:

553pb017a Brick, Round 2 x 2 Dome Top with Red Dots, Small Receptor and Dark Blue Pattern (R2-D2)
Parts: Brick, Round, Decorated

553pb017b Brick, Round 2 x 2 Dome Top with Lavender Dots, Small Receptor and Dark Blue Pattern (R2-D2)
Parts: Brick, Round, Decorated

So summarizing
- photo of dome for sw534 is correct
- dome for sw534 is classified under wrong entry
- sw534 has unique pattern printing which should have own catalog entry.

Here it is:

553pb034 Brick, Round 2 x 2 Dome Top with Silver Band Around Dome, Lime Dot Pattern (Astromech Droid)
Parts: Brick, Round, Decorated

I will correct then everything, thank you once again for finding this

Cheers
Marek

Author:

Hygrotus

Posted:

Dec 13, 2018 08:04

Subject:

Re: Inventory Change Request for Set 10194-1

Viewed:

20 times

Topic:

In Inventories Requests, Hygrotus writes:

In Inventories Requests, Teutsch writes:

Please make changes to the following inventory:

10194-1 (Inv) Emerald Night
1072 Parts, 3 Minifigures, 2009
Sets: Train: RC Train

* Add 1 Part 44375b Black Dish 6 x 6 Inverted (Radar) - Solid Studs (match ID 2)

Comments from Submitter:
I built my Emerald Night a month ago, MISB Set which I bought myself from Lego-Online-Store several years ago in Germany. The Set contains definately another version - my black dish has not any hollow studs, it has solid studs, so there is an alternate version of this set! If needed, I can send pictures of the LOT, Train itself, seals on packaging to locate the lego-factory my set got produced.

Please attach then pictures of your finding.
The only one which I fould with solid stud on this part is in this review:
https://youtu.be/b02yVGIH2xM?t=352
made by Australian Lego Fan, his speed build were always very good and usful
for checking variants he do them mostly from sealed set content (I trust his
reviews), but unluckily this one is older one from him so there isn't showed
box unpacking and bags unpacking

P.S.
I want to be here very carful for this variant here because when I was looking
for some more proofs I found many builds of lepin counterfeit showed on youtube
and in them this dish is with soild studs

Author:

Hygrotus

Posted:

Dec 13, 2018 08:03

Subject:

Re: Inventory Change Request for Set 10194-1

Viewed:

20 times

Topic:

In Inventories Requests, Teutsch writes:

Please make changes to the following inventory:

10194-1 (Inv) Emerald Night
1072 Parts, 3 Minifigures, 2009
Sets: Train: RC Train

Author:

Hygrotus

Posted:

Dec 13, 2018 07:48

Subject:

Re: Inventory Change Request for Minifig sw534

Viewed:

35 times

Topic: